Creating a Trust in Your Will vs. Creating a Living Trust
You've probably heard that trusts help families avoid probate court and protect assets for the people you love. Maybe you've even talked to a lawyer who mentioned including a trust in your will. It sounds like a good solution, but here's what most people don't realize: a trust created in your will works very differently from a living trust you create today, and the difference will have a major impact on your loved ones when you die.
Both options use the word "trust," which makes them sound similar. But the experience your family will have after your death depends entirely on which type you choose. More importantly, these different approaches serve different goals, and understanding what you're actually trying to accomplish is the most critical part of making the right choice.
In this two-part series, I'll help you understand what each type of trust actually does and how to choose the approach that matches what matters most to you and your loved ones. Here in Part 1, let’s dive into what happens when you create a trust in your will and help you evaluate what you're really trying to achieve.
What Happens When You Create a Trust in Your Will
A trust created in your will, called a testamentary trust, only comes into existence after you die, and after your executor has navigated a court process to establish the trust. Your will might say something like "upon my death, I direct that my assets be held in trust for my children until they reach age 25." This provision offers some protection by controlling when your children receive their inheritance. But it doesn't keep your family out of court.
All wills must go through probate court. Therefore, when you die with a will containing trust provisions, your loved ones must go through probate before the trust can be created. This process typically takes months, sometimes years. While your loved ones wait for the process to unfold, your assets are basically frozen, potentially putting your loved ones in an unstable financial position.
Here’s what the probate process looks like:
Your family must first locate your original will and file it with the probate court.
The court then officially appoints your named executor, who must notify all potential heirs and creditors of your death.
Your executor must gather all your assets, have them appraised, pay your debts and taxes, and prepare detailed accounting reports for the court.
Only after the court reviews and approves everything can your assets be distributed into the newly created trust, which must be approved by the judge.
Your family may also face significant costs. Probate involves court filing fees, legal fees, appraisal costs, and sometimes accounting fees. These expenses come directly out of your estate, reducing what's left for your loved ones. In many states, attorney fees and executor fees are calculated as a percentage of your estate's value. And because probate is a public court process, anyone can access information about what you owned and who you left it to.
Here's what really matters: you're essentially doing double the work to achieve the same outcome you could have accomplished with a living trust, but with added expense, a longer timeline, and far greater possibility for family conflict. You're creating a trust that provides the same protections a living trust offers, but you're forcing your family to go through an entire court process first. And that's only part of the problem. Because a will only takes effect when you die, it also leaves a critical gap in protection while you're still alive.
What a Will Can't Do While You're Still Alive
A will only takes effect when you die, which means it does nothing to protect you if you become incapacitated first. Most people rely on a Power of Attorney, or “POA,” to authorize someone to manage their finances if they're unable to do so. But here's the catch: a POA automatically ends the moment you die.
That creates a dangerous gap. The second you pass, your POA's authority disappears — but your executor has no power either until the probate court officially appoints them. Accounts get frozen, bills go unpaid, and your family can't touch a thing while they wait. A living trust eliminates this gap entirely. Because it exists right now, your successor trustee has uninterrupted authority to manage your assets through incapacity and seamlessly at your death — no court approval required, no delay, no financial limbo for your family.
All of this brings us to the most important question: what are you actually trying to accomplish? The gaps we've just covered - probate delays, frozen accounts, the POA cliff - aren't inevitable. They're the result of choosing a planning tool without first understanding your real goals.
What Are You Really Trying to Accomplish?
Before you can decide between a testamentary trust and a living trust, you need to get clear about what you're actually trying to achieve. Most people know they want "a trust" because someone told them trusts are good planning tools. But trusts accomplish different things depending on how they're structured.
Is your primary goal avoiding probate court? If keeping your family out of court matters to you, then how you create your trust makes a huge difference. A testamentary trust doesn't avoid probate. A living trust does. If probate avoidance is your main concern, that answer alone might determine your choice to create a living trust.
Do you want to control how and when your beneficiaries receive their inheritance? Maybe you have young children, and you don't want them inheriting everything at age 18. Both testamentary trusts and living trusts can accomplish these distribution goals. From a distribution control standpoint, both types of trusts can be structured identically. However, assets will not be available for your children during the probate process, so if availability is a concern for you, a living trust may be a good choice.
Do you want to protect your assets if you become incapacitated before you die? This is where the timing of trust creation makes a critical difference. A testamentary trust doesn't exist until you die, so it offers no protection during your lifetime. If you become unable to manage your affairs, your family would need to pursue guardianship or conservatorship proceedings in court. A living trust, however, allows your chosen successor trustee to step in and manage things for you without court intervention.
Understanding your true priorities helps clarify which approach makes sense. If your goals center entirely on controlling distributions and you're not concerned about probate costs or delays, then a testamentary trust might suffice. But if you want probate avoidance, incapacity protection, or immediate access to trust protections when you die, then the timing of when you create the trust becomes critically important.
Next week, in Part 2, I'll explain how living trusts work and how to make the final decision about which approach fits your situation.
How I Help You Identify What Matters Most
As a Personal Family Lawyer® Firm, we don't focus on the documents themselves because we believe documents are the byproduct of good planning. Planning starts with getting clear on what matters most, so our Life & Legacy Planning® process starts with education and understanding during a Life & Legacy Planning Session. During your session, you’ll get clear about what would actually happen to your family when you die or if you become incapacitated. We'll walk through the real costs, the real timeline, and the real experience your loved ones will face. Then we'll identify your true priorities so you can make an informed decision and create the right plan for you.
Last week, we covered how it works when you create a trust through your will. This week, I'll show you how a trust created during your lifetime (called a revocable living trust) functions differently, what your family experiences when you've set up a living trust, and how to decide which approach truly fits your situation.
As a quick refresher, a “testamentary trust” is created in your will and only comes into existence after your estate goes through probate. As a result, your family could wait many months, and sometimes even years, while the court oversees the process of probating your will and establishing your trust. If your objective is to keep your family out of court, and have total privacy after your incapacity or death, a testamentary trust won't accomplish that.
A living trust, created during your life, and properly “funded” will keep your family out of court, provide the privacy you likely want for them, and generally make things a lot easier for the people you love, when something happens to you.
In this article, I'll explain how living trusts provide those benefits, help you weigh the tradeoffs between the two approaches, and explain how to be your own best advisor, and make informed decisions.
How a Living Trust Works
A living trust, often called a revocable living trust, is created and funded while you're living and have legal capacity to make decisions. You transfer ownership of your assets into the trust now, naming yourself as the initial trustee. This means you maintain complete control during your lifetime. You can buy property, sell property, change investments, and manage everything exactly as you did before. The trust doesn't restrict you in any way.
The trust agreement includes detailed instructions about what happens to trust assets when you die or if you become incapacitated. Within the trust agreement, you will name a successor trustee, the person who will take over management of the trust assets when you can no longer serve as trustee. You specify who receives trust assets, when they receive them, and under what conditions. All the protective provisions you might include in a testamentary trust can be included in a living trust.
Here's the crucial distinction between a living trust and a testamentary trust: when you die or if you become incapacitated and cannot make decisions for yourself, the living trust already exists and already owns your assets. Your successor trustee doesn't need court permission to begin managing trust property. There's no probate filing. No waiting for court approval. No public disclosure of your assets or beneficiaries. The successor trustee simply follows the instructions you've provided in the trust agreement.
This means your family avoids the delay, expense, and public exposure of probate court. Your trustee can immediately pay bills, manage property, and begin distributing assets to your beneficiaries according to your timeline. If you've included provisions protecting your children's inheritance until they reach a certain age, those protections start working immediately. Your family gets the benefit of your planning right when they need it most.
The living trust also provides protection if you become incapacitated before you die. If illness, injury, or cognitive decline leaves you unable to manage your own affairs, your successor trustee can step in and handle things for you without requiring your family to go to court for guardianship proceedings. Your chosen successor simply steps into the role you've defined for them.
However - and this is critically important - living trusts only control assets that are actually transferred into the trust. In the world of estate planning lawyers, we call this "funding" the trust, and it's a crucial step many people overlook, even when working with a lawyer. If you create a living trust but never change the title on your house or retitle your bank accounts, then those assets aren't protected by the trust. When you die, those assets will need to go through probate. The trust can only control what it owns.
This is why working with a lawyer who has systems and processes set up specifically for estate planning, and ideally Life & Legacy Planning®, is so important. Creating a trust agreement is just the first step, and needs to be part of a full plan that covers all of your assets, ensures all of your assets are titled properly, all beneficiary designations are clarified and updated, and you are clear on how to keep everything up to date throughout the rest of your life. We have processes in our office for supporting just that.
Now that you understand how both types of trusts function, the question becomes: which one makes sense for your specific situation?
Understanding the Real Tradeoffs
Why would anyone choose a testamentary trust if living trusts offer so many advantages? The main reason comes down to upfront effort and cost. Creating a testamentary trust is usually less expensive initially because you're just adding provisions to your will. You don't have to transfer assets into a trust during your lifetime. All that happens in the probate process after you die.
For some, the cost of probate might not be substantial enough to justify the upfront expense of creating and funding a living trust. Others aren’t concerned about the probate process at all.
But consider the hidden costs your family will face. Even a simple probate proceeding typically costs several thousand dollars in legal fees and court costs. The process usually takes at least months, and often years. Your family must handle this while they're grieving, gathering documents, communicating with attorneys, and dealing with ongoing stress.
Compare that to the experience with a properly funded living trust. Your family meets with your successor trustee, who already knows what you wanted. They work together to handle immediate needs, notify beneficiaries, and distribute assets according to your wishes. The process is private, usually faster, and doesn't require court oversight. For most families, this experience is far less stressful and ultimately less expensive than probate.
Consider your family dynamics as well. If you have family members who might contest your wishes, the public nature of probate can fuel disputes. Anyone can access probate files and see what you left to whom. A living trust keeps everything private, which can help minimize conflict.
In addition, consider your specific assets and their complexity. If you own real estate in multiple states, you're facing probate proceedings in each state where you own property. A living trust holding all your real estate avoids this entirely. If you own a business, probate delays can harm business operations. A living trust allows seamless continuation of business management.
Understanding these tradeoffs helps clarify which approach makes sense for your situation. But you don't have to figure this out alone. Work with an experienced attorney - who’s also your trusted advisor - who can walk you through your specific circumstances so you’re confident you’re doing the right thing by those you love.
How I Help You Create a Plan That Actually Works
As a Personal Family Lawyer® Firm, we don't push everyone toward one type of trust. Instead, we start by helping you understand what will actually happen if you become incapacitated or when you die, based on the specifics of your family dynamics and your assets. We’ll walk you through the real costs, the real timeline, and the real experience your loved ones will face. Then we'll help you evaluate what matters most to you and make an informed decision that fits your desires and budget.
If a living trust makes sense for your situation, we won’t just create the document and send you on your way. We'll help you fund the trust properly, making sure assets are retitled correctly and nothing is overlooked. Then, we’ll make sure your plan stays up to date throughout your lifetime, and you have support when you need it throughout life.
Most importantly, we'll be there for your family when you're gone or if you become incapacitated. That ongoing relationship makes all the difference. Your loved ones won't be left alone trying to figure out what to do. They'll have a trusted advisor who knows you, knows your wishes, and can guide them when you can’t.
If you’d like this kind of care for yourself and the people you love, use this link to schedule a complimentary 15-minute discovery call to get started today.